Monday, February 13, 2012

Obama's Catholic Issue

Obama so-called accommodation with the Catholic Church is totally disingenuous. It is premised on a plan to require the insurance companies to provide contraceptives and abortion pills as a work around to his original plan to require faith-based institutions to provide them. To the shallow thinker this might be an attempt at compromise. However, it isn’t.

What is left in doubt is exactly who will actually pay for these services. The only way that this would be a sign of good faith would be that religious institutions would be given a reduced rate for their insurance proportional to cost of contraceptives and morning after pills. In that case all of the other costumers of the insurance companies would have increased rates to cover the cost of providing services to the religious organizations. While this might well serve the purpose of freeing the Church’s conscience, it would constitute the government mandating the financial support of religion. This would seem to violate current court interpretations of the First Amendment.

On the other hand if the religious organizations were not given a reduce rate then they would be providing contraceptives and abortion pills. In that case the Obama Administration offer would be a total sham. Furthermore, many of these organizations self-insure so who will pay in those cases?

This controversy is going to easily be swept under the rug. Nothing short of a complete rescission the Administration’s directive is acceptable.

No comments:

Post a Comment